I order chicken tikka masala the most whenever I go to an Indian restaurant. I love that it's coated in a delicious, creamy sauce that I can spoon over my rice or dip naan into. While I have ordered other dishes, of course, chicken tikka masala is usually what I crave. I bought a tikka masala sauce in a jar from the supermarket once, and it wasn't that great. After browsing through Ree Drummond's recipes, I decided to try to make it on my own. Granted, I could have used the recipe in a curry book a coworker bought me for one Christmas as a Secret Santa gift, but the amount of ingredients in that recipe overwhelmed me. Ree's recipe seemed much more doable.
_________________________________________________________________
Ingredients (serves 6)
- 3 whole (to 4) Chicken Breasts
- Kosher Salt
- Ground Coriander
- Cumin, To Taste
- 1/2 cup Plain Yogurt
- 6 Tablespoons Butter
- 1 whole Large Onion
- 4 cloves Garlic
- 1 piece (approximately 2 Inches) Chunk Fresh Ginger
- Garam Masala
- 1 can (28 Ounce) Diced Tomatoes
- Sugar
- 1-1/2 cup Heavy Cream
- 2 cups Basmati Rice
- _____
- OPTIONAL:
- Fresh Cilantro
- Chili Peppers
- Turmeric
- Frozen Peas
Preparation Instructions
Start by seasoning the chicken breasts with some kosher salt. Next sprinkle them on both sides with some coriander and cumin. Then coat the chicken breasts completely with the plain yogurt. Set the chicken on a metal cooling rack over a foil-lined baking sheet and place it about 10-12 inches below a broiler for 5-7 minutes per side. Watch carefully so as not to totally char the chicken. It should have slightly blackened edges. Remove from oven.
Next dice one large onion. In a large skillet melt 2 tablespoons butter over medium-high heat. Toss in the onions and sauté until they are slightly browned. As the onions cook, mince your garlic. Next, cut off the outer skin and mince or grate a 1 by 2 inch chunk of fresh ginger. Add the garlic and ginger to the onions. Also throw in about 1 tablespoon of salt.
Next you are going to add about 3 tablespoons Garam Masala spice. And if you like it hot, this is also when you will add your hot chili peppers. Serranos work well. Now you are going to add your can of diced tomatoes. Continue cooking and stirring, scraping the bottom of the pan to deglaze it. Add about 1 tablespoon sugar. Let this mixture simmer on medium for about 5 minutes.
To a rice cooker add 2 cups Basmati rice, 4 tablespoons butter, 1 teaspoon salt, 1 tablespoon Ground Turmeric and 4 cups water. Cover, turn on your rice cooker and walk away. If you do not have a rice cooker, cook your rice as usual but make sure that you use Basmati rice.
After the Tikka Masala sauce has had a chance to simmer for a little bit, add in the 1 ½ cups of heavy cream. Now, chop up your chicken breasts into chunks and stir them into the Tikka Masala sauce. A handful of chopped fresh cilantro is a nice addition if you like cilantro. You can also throw some frozen peas into the cooked rice, give them a stir, and allow the heat of the rice to cook the peas. It tastes great and gives another nice dash of color. Serve the rice with the Chicken Tikka Masala over top. Make sure to have some Nann bread handy, too.
I had almost all of the ingredients listed in her recipe, or was at least able to easily get them, except for the ground coriander. The supermarket closest to me didn't have it in stock so I trekked it to the next closest one (which my roommate affectionately calls Shangri-La because it has its own beer room). After I basically rearranged a good portion of the spice shelves there, I finally found a small package of ground coriander that would not have cost me damn near ten dollars. I settled on a small package of organic ground coriander that cost $2.75. Seriously? I thought to myself, when the fuck am I ever going to use this shit again? Could I just omit this mess? But I decided not to tempt fate.
I halved the recipe because I wasn't planning to feed an army and made a change to how I cooked the chicken. I was too lazy to fuss with the broiler so instead, I seasoned the chicken and coated it in yogurt as instructed but cooked the breasts in a skillet.
As I prepared the sauce, I realized my onions weren't chopped finely enough and neither were the canned diced tomatoes. Chunky tikka masala sauce, it is!
![]() |
| kinda looks like chili |
I might have added too much cream. I added more salt (I'm a bit of a salt fiend) and some cayenne pepper. Also, no cilantro for me because I hate the taste of it. Yes, I am one of those people who think it tastes like soap. I can handle it in small doses, but I tend to pick out any leaves in dishes I eat. When my mother made Vietnamese spring rolls (not the fried ones), I was always so confused as to why I thought it tasted absolutely delicious until I got maybe two bites in. The taste made me shudder. It took me only a few years to realize that it was that green, leafy shit she was adding. Once I got her to omit it, it was perfection.
The end result was pretty good, though I might have put too much ginger. It didn't taste like the dishes I ordered at Indian restaurants though. Maybe next time, I will try that recipe in my curry cookbook.











